Some people shop for a piano the way they shop for a sofa: size, finish, price, delivery date. And then there are people who hear one instrument and feel the floor tip. Perri Knize belongs to the second group, and Grand Obsession: A Piano Odyssey—published by Scribner in 2008, later a Washington Post “Best of 2008” and a New York Times Editor’s Choice—is the memoir of what that kind of listening can cost, and what it can give back.

If you are contemplating your first piano, Knize’s book is both a romance and a cautionary tale in the best sense. It says: trust your ear. It also says: sound is not a fixed property stamped on an instrument at the factory. Tone can bloom, fade, travel, and—with skilled hands—return.

Book cover of Grand Obsession by Perri Knize
Grand Obsession: A Piano Odyssey by Perri Knize (Scribner). Cover used for review illustration.

From Modest Upright to a Rare German Grand

The publisher’s opening chapter, “Epiphany,” begins in the autumn of Knize’s forty-third year—not with a showroom, but with a cassette of Arthur Rubinstein playing Chopin waltzes in her car beside Montana’s Boulder River. The sense of missed possibility is immediate. Her father, formerly a professional clarinetist, had trained her ear closely, yet her childhood request for piano lessons was redirected toward school instruments. She tried cello and flute; piano lessons came later, in young adulthood, including study in Mannes College of Music’s nondegree program. Then practical pressures interrupted them, and fifteen years passed.

Her return is not a tale of instant confidence. At the University of Montana she meets Dr. Jody Graves, feels intimidated by a student’s playing, and sits down with shaking hands to try a Chopin nocturne. Her fingers remember more than she expects. Graves refers her to a master’s student; that teacher’s graduation later interrupts the new routine. This is a valuable beginning for hesitant readers: a musical life can restart through an encouraging teacher and imperfect circumstances, not only through an expensive purchase.

The wider journey, described in the publisher’s synopsis, takes her from a search for an affordable upright to a German grand in New York. Kirkus identifies it as a Grotrian Cabinet grand. Knize calls the piano Marlene, a name also confirmed in her publisher biography. She refinances her Montana home to buy it—but after delivery, the sound that captivated her is missing. That disappointment, rather than the acquisition itself, sets the larger investigation in motion.

A Quest Into the Hidden World of Tone

According to the author’s synopsis, the investigation takes her to the technician who prepared the instrument in New York, to its builders in Germany, and to the Austrian Alps to learn about the trees used in piano making. Those later scenes remain supported by the author’s account of the book, not by full chapters available for this check. One brief phrase quoted there catches the original attraction: “The middle section is smoky and mysterious.” The descriptive language is intensely personal, as piano listening often is.

What makes the opening particularly rewarding is the tension between musical nourishment and musical pressure. Her father taught her to listen deeply, but his disappointed ambitions also made choosing an instrument feel heavy. Her mother’s player piano and her grandfather’s informal playing offer another model: music as family delight. An aspiring player can recognize both inheritances—the wish to do music well and the need to enjoy it without an examination waiting at the end.

There is a caution here for prospective buyers, too. Knize’s financial leap is an individual choice, not a recommendation to overextend a household budget. You can take your musical wishes seriously without requiring one rare grand to fulfill them all. The opening’s rediscovery of touch and its welcoming teacher are as important as the later instrument search. Nor should the story be reduced to a diagnosis that humidity alone explains Marlene’s changed sound: the accessible chapter does not establish the eventual technical answer.

Why Aspiring Owners Should Read It

For a prospective owner, the useful questions are concrete. Which sound draws you in? Does the action let you shape a phrase comfortably? What condition is the instrument in, and what work might it need? A book can sharpen those questions, but it cannot replace trying the piano and discussing its condition with a technician. For a returning player, the opening offers an equally valuable question: who could help you feel welcome at the keyboard again?

Has Knize’s search stirred your own? Renaissance Piano Service can help you look for the piano of your dreams—or explore why a piano you once loved no longer feels or sounds inviting. Restoration, regulation, and voicing address different needs; the right starting point is an assessment, not a promise of a particular result. Contact us to discuss a piano search or your existing instrument.

Read Grand Obsession when you are ready to take your own ear seriously. It will not hand you a shopping spreadsheet. It will do something better: it will remind you that the right piano is not merely purchased. It is recognized—and then cared for—as a relationship.

Reading note: The publisher’s complete displayed Chapter 1, “Epiphany,” was read for this review. Later travel and purchase details were checked against the publisher’s and author’s synopses, not the full book. Source and available text.